
Key Points
With 52 pedals in the signal chain, compact enclosures and pedalboard-friendly formats matter. The preference is generally for single compact enclosures, while oversized vintage formats take too much floor and storage space. Width is often the main constraint in “Pedalboard Tetris”.
Chris Benson and Tom Cram largely favour horizontal 1590BB formats. Benson Amps and Spiral Electric FX make beautiful pedals, but girth affects acquisition decisions. The examples are the Benson Amps Deep Sea Diver Fuzz-Echo and Spiral Electric FX Brute Fuzz; the compact Demhe Fuzz is the only Spiral Electric FX pedal owned.
Knob choice, aesthetics, jack location, pedal storage and personal preferences all influence format decisions.
It’s fairly well documented by now that I mostly favour Single Compact Enclosures - especially when there’s only a single footswitch present. I do go larger for the occasional pedal - like my various Stereo Workstation Pedals for instance, and my Drum Machine - while by and large I always try to get something in a fully practical and easily slottable form factor.
My rig / board is highly congested, and has been for a while, now with 52 pedals in the signal chain - so in many circumstances I’m somewhat constrained to compact formats - in order to be able to fit everything in that I want to. And generally I tend tp steer clear of unnecessarily oversized formats - like say all those original vintage ones for instance - they just have way too large a footprint and take up way too much floor space for me! I really don’t see the point of them - I feel it’s a little like still wanting to drive around in a Ford Model T!
There are a number of builders though - which make truly great pedals, but wholly stick to the horizontal 1590BB format rather than deliver a more practical and pedalboard-friendly vertical orientation - after all it’s almost always the width of a pedal that is the most significant limiting factor with regards to pedalboard placement - something which I frequently refer to as ’Pedalboard Tetris’!
For sake of example - I’ve referenced two of my favourite brands here that near enough wholly stick to the horizontal format and which therefore inadvertently render their pedals somewhat non-pedalboard-friendly and ill-fitting for my rig.
There are a tonne of builders who favour vertical enclosures - and I’m not always clear as to why those brands that persist with horizontal formats continue to do so!
If Chris Benson or Tom Cram made more vertical formats - I’m sure I would have more of those pedals in my references collection. Those brands make beautiful pedals - but they always lose out in the practicality stakes for me - based on their girth! In fact the only Spiral Electric FX pedal I own to date is their compact Demhe Fuzz - where I encouraged Tom to make more in a similar format - which successful rollout he’s somehow chosen not to replicate a second time? I’ve always liked the look of his Brute and Allora Fuzzes - but never quite hit the trigger yet for all he reasons discussed here in this blog!
I know Tom Cram uses a lot of cool custom pedal knobs - and he has more freedom to fit those in on a horizontal format - while Chris mostly uses those rather slimline MXR type knobs - so I would presume it mostly comes down to aesthetic choice for both those builders mentioned.
As is always the case - I’m keen to hear from all you pedal fans as to how much the format of enclosure size and orientation influences your purchasing decisions. I know some people out there are almost militant in wanting compact pedals with top-mounted jacks - and won’t buy anything else. I’m a little less precious about where the jacks are located - as that depends a lot on the nature and construction of the circuit - It’s a nice to have for me rather than a blocker.
Obviously you can’t be anti side-mounted jacks if you’re a fan of Boss Pedals like me. Several brands still continue to do side-mounted jacks - which I’m mostly kind of alright with!
So the question is really - what influences your purchasing and acquistion decision making as regards different pedal formats and enclosure orientation?
The 2 pedals featured here are the Benson Amps Deep Sea Diver Fuzz-Echo which I recently covered, and the Spiral Electric FX Brute Fuzz, now with slightly different knobs - both are of course great pedals, and both of which have appeared on my wishlist - but never quite made it to must-buy acquisition status - likely because of their somewhat lesser pedalboard-friendliness of format!
I get that on my verticak Brute Fuzz visual the top 3 knobs are a little congested - while there is still sufficient space around them to operate each of those in relative comfort. Probably you would choose slightly different knobs in that orientation - which brings us back again to the question of aesthetic choice!
This is of course mostly just about personal preferenes - but also pedalboard practicalities! I hope you enjoyed this ride!
Note that it’s also a matter of pedal storage - and not just Pedal Tetris - the bigger the pedals are the trickier they are to stove away, and the more space they end up taking over!


