
Key Points
Across the four Keeley 4-in-1 pedals, the favourite settings ranked: Blues Disorder OC+BB; Noble Screamer OD+OD, then OD+TS; Blues Disorder OC+OC; Super Rodent RT+SD, then SD+SD; Angry Orange MF+DS, then DS+DS.
OC+BB was the overall favourite, while Noble Screamer was top pedal by a smidge; Blues Disorder was nearly joint first. Super Rodent was even across all four settings but placed third. Angry Orange sounded decent alone yet comparatively thin and less potent, especially against Keeley’s Ultra Modded DS-1.
The stated MAP/RRP was $199 US, €259 EU and £199 UK, direct and through dealers.
So I’ve obviously covered each of these pedals individually and in real depth - so please refer to the earlier articles if you need more details. The purpose of this exercise is to pick out my favourite/s from the series - which is really about comparing those 4 pedals head-to head across my 2 favourite settings for each - pitting one against the other - back and forth - until we have a preferences.
Note - that if you want to skip all the preamble - you can just scroll down to the bottom picture below which reveals all!
So in order of how I reviewed these - my favourite 2 settings for each pedal were as follows :
Noble Screamer
Blues Disorder
Super Rodent
Angry Orange
So when I tested the pedals the first time around - I was really just interested in how each of those settings combinations sounded against the other - I only did the exercise comparing across pedals right at the end, and a couple come out a little more potent, and one sounds a touch ’thin’ in comparison to the others, as will be revealed below.
I gave each of those voicings a fair shake - and even tested the 3rd favourite settings for each - just to make sure I got it right the first time around. And for sure those same 2 settings rise up as favourites as before - which is good sign.
In any case - I went back and forth over a lengthy session spanning a couple of days in the end - to establish which of those voicings were the most special, and my favourite voicings in order of preferences are revealed below!

So my favourite setting across all 4 pedals is the BluesBreaker Clipping with the OCD Tone Stack on the Blues Disorder - I really love that, while overall in the rankings the Noble Screamer ends up as top dog. I could have made the Noble Screamer and Blues Disorder joint first in some ways - but I was determined to have a proper ordered ranking here - and the Noble Screamer wins overall by smidge on account of the supremacy of both of its top voicings - which end up jointly being just fractionally ahead of the the 2 Blues Order ones - on a different day the Blues Order might have come first - they're both great in any case!
Funnily the two top ranking pedals both have a weak 4th Setting onboard, while the Super Rodent is pretty even across all 4 of its Settings - there is no noticeable weak link as there is for the others. In the early running I thought that the Super Rodent might be the favourite - but in comparing and contrasting those pedals back and forth - the Super Rodent only takes 3rd spot. The Noble Screamer and Blues Order are simply just more satisfying to me!
And when you're testing the Angry Orange on its own - it sounds pretty decent, but as soon as you compare it to the other 3 it falls a little bit short of those - they just sound better balanced, more impressive and overall more potent. I said that the MF + DS setting had a tiny hint of Robert's DS-1 Ultra Mod - but it's not really close enough - the Ultra Mod is significantly beefed up - which the DS-1 really needs when going into a Clean Pedal Platform setup - as it was original designed to push an already on-the-edge amp. The DS-1 was the first pedal I ever bought - and I was actually disappointed with it - until I found my way to Keeley Ultra Modded version of the same. I now have 9 versions of the DS-1 - 10 with Angry Orange - and all are better than the original - while the Angry Orange could have been even better with a more beefed up DS-1 voicing. Without the extra beef it sounds a touch thin and insubstantial compared to the other much better voicings.
So after an extensive cogitation and consideration - I found that my preference for those pedals was exactly as per the order I reviewed them! There's not a lot between the Noble Screamer and Blues Disorder - where even by some criteria the Blues Disorder is the better pedal.
This took a long deliberation - and I 100% stand by my deliberations - as per the final visual below - those are the best sounding voicings ranked in order, and on the periphery the position of the 4 pedals.
I hope you found this exercise as helpful and illuminating as me - I feel that all the 4-in-1 Series are worthwhile - where understandably - some are rather more worthwhile than others!
The 4 x 4-in-Series pedals are all priced at MAP / RRP $199 in the US, €259 in the EU, and £199 in the UK, of course available direct from the Keeley Electronics Webstore, and at all leading dealers!

