
Key Points
Three limited-edition Tube Screamers are compared: TS808 Red, TS9 Gold and TSV808. Listed original prices were $285, $150 and $450; current median resale values were $330, $385 and $1,750. TSV808 had five controls, two internal dips, and around 2,000 made; production figures for the others were unavailable.
Quantitatively, TS9 Gold wins (#1, 21), TS808 Red ranks second (22), and TSV808 third (24). TSV808 gained six #1 rankings, including versatility, quality, uniqueness and desirability, and was the author’s personal winner despite pricing. Reverb availability was highest for TSV808. The article proposes future Boss Fuzz comparisons and notes incomplete, sometimes unreliable data.
| TS808 Red | TS9 Gold | TSV808 | |
| Original Price ($) | $285 (#2) | $150 (#1) | $450 (#3) |
| Current Price (μ) | $330 (#1) | $385 (#2) | $1750 (#3) |
| No. of Controls | 3 (#2=) | 3 (#2=) | 5 + 2 intl. dips (#1) |
| Numbers Made | N/A | N/A | c2,000 |
| Affordability (now) | #1 | #2 | #3 |
| Ease of Use | #1= | #1= | #3 |
| Obtainability (Rvrb) | #3 (8) | #2 (11) | #1 (25) |
| Practicality | #1= | #1= | #3 |
| Versatility | #2= | #2= | #1 |
| Quality | #2= | #2= | #1 |
| Uniqueness | #2= | #2= | #1 |
| Value | #2 | #1 | #3 |
| Desirability | #3 | #2 | #1 |
| VERDICT | #2 (22) | #1 (21) | #3 (24) |
$ - Pricing in $USD
μ - Median value for Current Resale / Second Hand Price
So if you want to rank these Quantitively then you simply add up the individual rankings by criteria / category - and the lowest total wins (VERDICT) - i.e. thee TS9 Gold. All of that still involves some Qualitative appraisal - so you can skip the maths if you wish - and simply go by gut feel - or ideally a combination of both approaches! Note that we had to exclude ranking for ’Numbers Made’ as there simply isn’t the data to support that - hence mostly N/A. Finally, you can also rank overall by most number of #1 rankings - which hands it to the TSV808 (6).
Not that for different themes and groupings some of the criteria will likely vary - especially pedals which are in current general supply - don’t need the Median (μ) Current Resale Price,
For me and my preferences - even though the pricing and a few of the categories are against it - I have the TSV808 as my own personal overall winner in this context and contest even - funnily enough it also has the most availability on Reverb.com - silly pricing currently though - so even though it’s the one I want the most - I’m almost entirely unlikely to get one within current prevailing conditions!
Do analyse the above data set yourselves and draw your own conclusions and extrapolations / interpolations - and report them in the comments below. I’m looking to do a series of these 3-way head-to-heads - and the pedals covered of course need to be within a comparable theme - so let me know what further episodes you might like to see of these. I’m thinking I might do Boss Fuzzes next - probably FZ-1W, FZ-2 and TB-2W! Or possibly FZ-1W, FZ-2, FZ-3 if you prefer! Or just the super rare ones - FZ-2, FZ-3 and TB-2W - you decide!
It’s funny how poor the Internet still is on some details - all 3 here are obviously limited editions, but I was unable to find official figures for how many were made - beyond a quoted 400 TSV808’s made for USA - not the global total. Also several brands are poor on the details we often need - in order to properly analyse the value and merit of each proposition - so there’s a degree of grey science here - and some of the data may not be entirely 100% accurate. Note also some rounding of figures for sake of aesthetics!
In any case - this is just supposed to be harmless fun and spark some lively debate - also leading to really cool visuals of course.
All of this is to be taken with a pinch of salt - i.e not taken too seriously - and latterly / eventually it will be more of group-think in determining what gets which overall rank. I do hope you enjoyed this first edition - here follow some salient demos! :
